Why markets are not as overvalued as you might think.

And why the Shiller PE Ratio is broken.

Look back metrics for valuing markets say that the stock market is overvalued. But there is a big problem with lagging metrics like Shiller PE (the CAPE Ratio), the growth rate of company earnings has quadrupled over the last three decades.

If we allow for the fact earnings growth rates have significantly increased as a result of technology, stocks are not as overvalued as you might think.

Shiller PE says we are overvalued

The Shiller PE (also known as the CAPE Ratio) is a market price-earnings ratio often used as a yardstick to assess relative over- and under-valuation of equities. It takes the ratio of the S&P500 to its inflation-adjusted earnings from the previous 10 years.

With a value of 29, the Shiller PE is still measuring higher valuations today than the peak of 1929 and 2008. A simplistic conclusion here would be that a 50% drop in the Shiller PE would not be out of the ordinary for stocks to reach equilibrium. Such a PE compression to the mean would likely require stock prices to collapse by a comparable order of magnitude. That sounds like bad news for stock investors.

Shiller PE tracks the relative stock market value. Simply: higher is bearish, lower is bullish. Today’s reading is higher than the 1929 and 2008 pre-crash levels. Source: Multpl

But it’s not that simple.

Since 1995, for the last 27 years, the average Shiller PE has been 27.8.
But for the 100 years before that, the average Shiller PE was 14.6.

What happened in 1995?

There are only two ways to explain this doubling in valuations for the last three decades. Either the markets have been growing in an ever inflating bubble, or there was drastic economic change over that period.

The reality lies somewhere in the middle.

Technology + Metcalf’s Law = the game changer

The last 50-years has not only been incredibly peaceful, but we saw globalization and technology take a giant leap forward. We had the invention of modern day computers and the internet; the latter of which went exponential in the mid-90s and drove the world closer together.

Technology adoption S-curves. The Internet and telecommunications went exponential in the 1990s. Source: Michael Felton, the New York Times

A logical argument can be made that technology (the internet especially) has created new network effects that result in higher earnings of businesses (think Amazon, Google, Microsoft) and people (solopreneurs, podcasters, dropshippers and more). This is a result of the exponential benefits associated with network growth, also known as Metcalf’s law.

In short — Metcalf’s law says the value of a network grows with the square of each additional node (user/connection) added. In layman’s terms, the internet has shrunk economic boundaries and exponentially increased the potential impact and value any individual person or entity can derive in business today.

Under such a massive technological revolution, business earnings have also been moving along an S-curve.

As a result, one could argue that the trailing 10 years of earnings that the Shiller PE Ratio uses is too lagging and is not representative of current and future profits that modern businesses generate.

And there is quantifiable evidence for this.

Baseline Growth is 4X higher now

Since 1995, real earnings per share have increased over 400%.

It took almost 100 years to achieve that same growth rate in earnings before the mid-90s. This generation has indeed seen S&P500 earnings grow 300% faster annually compared to the prior century.

This completely explains the higher Shiller PE scores over the last three decades. By definition, Shiller PE uses data which is on average 5 years old, but earnings have been growing at an astounding 15% p.a., versus just 4% p.a. for the prior centuryThis isn’t just a one off phenomenon, this is how baseline growth has been for the last three decades.

By simple math: compounding 15% p.a. over 5 years results in a 100% increase. In other words, the average earnings used in the Shiller PE ratio should be expected to be almost 50% lower than actual earnings today.

S&P500 Inflation adjusted earnings grew about 4X faster in the last decades. Source: Capriole Investments

Not overvalued after all

So the denominator of Shiller PE (earnings) is using a value half of what businesses were actually earning at any point in time in the last three decades.

The implication?

Shiller PE values are effectively double what they would be if earnings were not lagged and therefore the market is not nearly as overvalued as the Shiller PE would suggest.

Therefore for the post 1995 era, we should expect stocks to show valuations double their prior long-term average.

The doubling in average Shiller PE Ratio over the last 30 years is completely explained by the 4X increase in average yearly earnings growth, and not a sign of overvaluation. Source: Multpl

Put another way, if asset prices and current earnings stayed exactly the same for the next decade, the Shiller PE would fall by about half, as the divisor (10 year average earnings) slowly increases each year and plays catch up to reality.

When you think about it that way, equities don’t sound so overvalued after all.

Summary

Markets are not as overpriced as you may think. In fact, they are fairly valued.

The internet brought an era of 300% higher average annual earnings growth rates over the last three decades, which is skewing lagging valuation metrics like Shiller PE and CAPE Ratio and presenting an erroneous picture.

A Shiller PE of 28 today means equities are fairly valued based on historic growth.

Now it’s up to you to determine if you think historical growth rates are relevant going forward.

The Capriole Fund

The Capriole Fund has one goal: outperform Bitcoin.

We are open to professional investors, but the fund has limited spaces.

Share the Post:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Disclaimer

The information contained here is provided to you solely for informational purposes only. Opinions and projections included are provided as of the date of publication, may prove to be inaccurate, and are subject to change without notice. This information does not constitute an offering. Prospective investors should not treat these materials as advice regarding legal, tax, or investment matters. No recommendations are made to invest in Capriole Investments Limited nor any other investment. An offering may be made only by delivery of a confidential offering memorandum to appropriate investors. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Investing in digital assets in general involves risk. Digital asset risks include, but are not limited to, exchange risk, legal risk, hacking risk, market risk, liquidity risk, trading risk and default risk. As with any investment, investing in digital assets could result in loss of investment. Additional digital asset risks are outlined at www.capriole.com/legal. Decisions or actions based on the information provided are at the reader’s own account and risk.

Related Posts

Update #51

Hash Ribbons is back. Perhaps the best long-term Bitcoin buy signal there...

Charles Edwards

Update #50

Is Bitcoin's longest winning streak finally coming to an end?...

Charles Edwards

Update #49

A dive on the forth Bitcoin Halving, Runes, Onchain valuations and macroeconomic...

Charles Edwards

Update #48

Welcome to Bitcoin price discovery, it's been a long time coming. With...

Charles Edwards

Update #47

The era of deep value is over. Bitcoin is fairly valued for...

Charles Edwards

Update #46

With the big Fidelity news, Bitcoin is finally being acknowledged in traditional...

Charles Edwards

Update #45

The brand names of these two behemoths in the traditional asset space...

Charles Edwards

Update #44

Today's Bitcoin ETF launch was the most successful launch in history and...

Charles Edwards

Update #43

ETF fever is coming to a head with approvals expected within the...

Charles Edwards

Update #42

Two major and positive events just unfolded in the Bitcoin space. According...

Charles Edwards

Update #41

Bitcoin is heating up, in both opportunity and across derivatives markets. And...

Charles Edwards

Issue #40

A new major trend has formed. We now have the biggest asset...

Charles Edwards

Issue #39

We have historically rare risk-asset signals appearing, amidst a period of Bitcoin's...

Charles Edwards

Issue #38

The last week has seen the biggest improvements across Bitcoin technicals and...

Charles Edwards

Issue #37

Bitcoin is pricing as a better-and-better inflation hedge. It is rapidly skewing...

Charles Edwards

Issue #36

The Fed is Building a War Chest. A macroeconomic deep dive to...

Charles Edwards

Issue #35

We are seeing some promising and rare structures form on Bitcoin which...

Charles Edwards

Issue #34

All else equal, Bitcoin is like a beach ball submerged underwater. Nonetheless,...

Charles Edwards

Issue #33

Last update technicals and fundamentals told us to be cautious with Bitcoin....

Charles Edwards

The Three Factor Model

90% of the S&P500 returns over the last half century can be...

Charles Edwards

Issue #32

Welcome to Capriole’s micro update #1. Where we consolidate the most important...

Charles Edwards

Issue #31

At $29K, Bitcoin’s on-chain fundamentals are not too hot and not too...

Charles Edwards

Issue #30

The failures of the Federal Reserve in managing the value of money...

Charles Edwards

Issue #29

This newsletter explores a taboo topic. The idea of the impossible, a...

Charles Edwards

Issue #28

Bitcoin’s deep value is slipping away and in its place a new...

Charles Edwards

Issue #27

We believe the 2020s will be the decade of hard money, much...

Charles Edwards

Why markets are not as overvalued as you might think.

Charles Edwards

Issue #26

The crypto world was shaken to the core in November as top...

Charles Edwards

Bitcoin Miner Sell Pressure

Charles Edwards

The Bitcoin Yardstick

Charles Edwards

Issue #25

We crack open the rarest of Bitcoin value metric readings you can...

Charles Edwards

Everything you need to know about yield curves

Charles Edwards

Issue #24

This month we deep dive into the macro and make the case...

Charles Edwards

SLRV Ribbons

Charles Edwards

Issue #23

Fear struck the market again with a blunt Fed speech. The broader...

Charles Edwards

Issue #22

This issue we deep dive into the many Bitcoin and macro metrics...

Charles Edwards

Issue #21

Today, we now find ourselves in a special juncture in the crypto...

Charles Edwards

The Digital Asset Thesis

Charles Edwards

The Capriole Macro Index

Charles Edwards

Issue #20

The S&P500 and Bitcoin showcased a strong recovery recently and today both...

Charles Edwards

Issue #19

Traditional markets have been taking a beating. Our February Newsletter and analysis...

Charles Edwards

Issue #18

The first quarter of 2022 is coming to a close. War in...

Ryan McCoy

Issue #17

For the past few months, Bitcoin has been driven by macro events...

Yassine Zrigui

Issue #16

Last month was mostly dominated by macro news much like December, namely...

Mick Herfkens

Capriole’s 2022 Market Outlook

A year ago, we published our “Christmas Special” newsletter. We wrote the...

Charles Edwards

Issue #15

If you have been around the cryptospace long enough, you have probably...

Ryan McCoy

Issue #14

Bitcoin started the month of November strong with a new all time...

Mick Herfkens

Issue #13

Bitcoin is up over 30% to date in October, reaching as high...

Charles Edwards

A Simple Metric to Identify Bitcoin Tops

Charles Edwards

Issue #12

Last issue, at $47K we noted some concerning metrics, but noted the...

Charles Edwards

Issue #11

Last issue we noted the improving fundamentals for Bitcoin...

Charles Edwards

Issue #10

Last issue we reviewed the China’s crypto exodus and argued why we...

Charles Edwards

Issue #9

These are unprecedented times. The Bitcoin network has just experienced the biggest...

Charles Edwards

Issue #8

Bitcoin is trading at more than 40% below the all-time high for...

Jan Uytenhout

Issue #7

Every month we write a short update on the market. We try...

Charles Edwards

Issue #6

Every month we write a short update on the market. Last issue,...

Jan Uytenhout

Issue #5

Every month we write a short update on the market. We try...

Charles Edwards

Issue #4

Every month we write a short update on the market. We try...

Jan Uytenhout

Issue #3

Every month we write a short update on the market. We try...

Charles Edwards

Issue #2

We try to release our newsletters when we see key opportunities. Today...

Jan Uytenhout

What is Money?

Charles Edwards

Issue #1

This newsletter provides our airplane view of the Bitcoin market. It summarises...

Charles Edwards

The Energy Standard

Charles Edwards

Bitcoin Energy-Value Equivalence

Charles Edwards

Bitcoin’s Production Cost

Charles Edwards

Hash Ribbons & Bitcoin Bottoms

Charles Edwards

Metcalfe’s Law Says Bitcoin is Overvalued

Charles Edwards

Bitcoin Valuation using Dynamic Range NVT Signal

Charles Edwards

The Next Resession

Charles Edwards

Bitcoin Bottom Fishing with Miner Capitulation

Charles Edwards