Update #55

Is Retail dead?

Welcome to Capriole’s Newsletter Update #55. A consolidation of the most important Bitcoin news, technicals and fundamentals.

This issue we explore the conundrum that faces Bitcoin today, an apparent lack of retail on-exchange activity and declining active address numbers despite Bitcoin trading at $72K. Since the FTX collapse in 2022, a trust void has plagued Bitcoin and crypto trading.

Will retail activity return?

Retail Speculation is Dead

Active Bitcoin Addresses, the number of addresses that are transacting, is at the same level as the lows of 2016, 2018 and 2019. Well below the levels set in the 2017 bull market and 2020/21 bull market.

Since the FTX collapse in November 2022, in-house exchange volumes, the amount of BTC moving between wallets on exchange, is still below the floor of the 2017-2021 cycle. This metric has clearly seen no like-for-like BTC growth since the FTX collapse. This suggests exchange activity has not recovered from FTX.

On the following chart you can see the 6 month sum of exchange in- and out-flows has been at and below zero since 2022 (new outflows). The extent of this phenomena has not been seen ever before in Bitcoin’s history. This suggests a continued lack of trust in exchanges (and/or in the benefits of trading on centralized exchanges) since the FTX fraud.

The next chart shows spot trading volumes in BTC. Again we see no growth since FTX, despite massive price appreciation, spot trading volumes are still less than 2020 and 2021.

Total Futures trading volumes (incl. Perpetuals) is way down from 2021. This is a significant drop in on-exchange leveraged speculation.

The next chart shows the relative Open interest (percentages) across Bitcoin derivatives markets covering Perpetuals, Options and Other Futures products. The chart suggest Perpetuals lost their lead in 2023, with Options taking the dominant market position today. This is indicative of the institutionalisation of Bitcoin, and a move away to the historic leadership of Perpetual contracts under a largely retail driven market pre-2022. Is the 100X leverage era gone?

The next chart shows the total derivatives market open interest (OI) is largely flat since the FTX fraud. The shaded light-blue area is the ratio of total OI to volume across derivatives markets. OI/volume is up about 300%. This represents a lot less trading turnover for a similar magnitude of total Bitcoin derivative positions; which suggests the market is taking on less speculation trades, and instead perhaps opting for more long-term positions and cash-and-carry arbitrage trades, a phenomenon also well discussed in a recent Glassnode newsletter.

With OI at circa $42B today, one crypto native entity alone represents around 5% of that figure. Ethena, the crypto native cash-and-carry protocol arbitraging BTC and ETH perpetual futures funding rates. If just one crypto native entity represents 5% of OI, you can imagine that across the entirety of crypto and across the US Bitcoin ETFs (which alone now have assets under management near 2X the total Bitcoin derivatives OI); a significant chunk of OI that we see today is from institutionalized cash-and-carry trades and other market making activities.

Where is Retail?

However, despite the low activity readings in on-chain and on-exchange data above, we conversely see that the number of Bitcoin investors worldwide (those with at least $100 on a wallet) is expanding rapidly in 2024 and consistently hitting new all time highs.

We can also see an industry wide preference for Bitcoin over other altcoins since the FTX collapse, with Bitcoin market dominance (its share versus the total crypto marketcap) growing from 40% to 60% today. A similar story can be told by simply looking at Ethereum’s performance, both across price (poor) and its comparable US ETF launch (lacklustre uptake).

Presented a bit differently below, we see that total crypto market cap excluding Bitcoin (i.e. all altcoins) is still down -40% from 2021 highs. Again highlighting the market preference for Bitcoin since 2022.

We also see on-chain transactions are booming in 2024. As the below chart shows, all of this Bitcoin on-chain transaction growth is fully explained by the rise of Inscriptions and Runes. Net of these two, on-chain activity is actually down. In short, all of Bitcoin’s transaction growth in 2024 is from Runes as of writing. All speculative growth here is in Inscriptions and Runes. By way of example, Runes can be used for Bitcoin native NFTs (digital art) and Memecoins.

Other notable areas of crypto growth in the last year include Memecoins, which have seen their market capitalization grow from $14B to over $63B today across all cryptocurrencies (per CoinMarketCap).

And of course, we have the massive growth of Bitcoin ETFs, whose holdings have reached 1M coins in less than a year. That’s over 5% of all supply when you exclude lost coins.

This tells us that retail traders:

  1. Have a stronger preference for investing and hodling Bitcoin (on-chain and via ETFs)
  2. Are not utilising centralized exchanges and leverage like in previous cycles (yet)
  3. Are buying less altcoins
  4. Conducting limited speculation at the fringes, mostly on-chain (Runes, memecoins)

Implications

Very healthy, Sustainable Bitcoin Appreciation

All of this suggests a very healthy Bitcoin rally to $72K today. While we are trading near all time highs, we have not yet seen speculation near the levels of prior Bitcoin cycles and bull runs (2016-17, 2020-21). Strong crypto markets are formed by strong Bitcoin leadership which then allows capital to flow down stream. Provided Bitcoin’s relative strength can continue beyond prior all time highs without dramatic increases in market leverage, this sets a positive frame for late 2024 and 2025.

Institutional Adoption

At the same time we have seen increased institutional adoption of Bitcoin via ETFs, and from the growing use of Tradfi dominant products (options and CME futures). As Ki shows, over 1000 institutional investment managers (investment firms with over $100M in assets) now represent approximately 20% of Bitcoin ETF holders. This number doesn’t include smaller asset manager and other companies holding Bitcoin ETFs on their balance sheet. That means 10s of billions of dollars are being invested in the Bitcoin ETFs by businesses in 2024.

Not to mention Microstrategy alone which now holds $18B Bitcoin.

If retail speculation is low, and institutional adoption of Bitcoin is growing rapidly, this suggests a very “Player-vs-Player” (PvP) environment today, where those actively trading Bitcoin and altcoins (especially on exchange) are up against experienced professionals, making it a more challenging trading environment at present.

Funding Rates low signal

It also suggests historically powerful predictive metrics like “funding rates” are not very valuable at present; because:

  1. Funding rates are being dampened by cash-and-carry traders (like Ethena), adding noise to the signal
  2. More trading is longer-term (lower leverage and lower risk)
  3. Retail isn’t using leverage like it has in the past, and
  4. Perpetual futures market share has collapsed in the last 2 years against Options and CME. So they have much less importance in the market.

A once incredibly powerful trading signal in Funding rates is a lot less useful today. This could all change very quickly with the resurgence of retail traders in the future.

Going Forward

Despite Bitcoin being up 4X since the FTX collapse, exchange activity and use of retail leverage has remained constrained. Bitcoin as a safehaven has been the preferred investment approach and despite all the social chatter about Memecoins, their market share remains less than 3% of the total Crypto market cap today ($2.4T).

If history is anything to go by, we usually see renewed growth in speculation type activities when Bitcoin trends beyond all time highs. This era may be just in front of us, opening up a more speculation driven environment, stronger retail growth and broader price appreciation across cryptocurrencies. A more “Player-vs-Environment” landscape. That trigger may be increased certainty following conclusion of the US election.

Charles Edwards

The Capriole Fund

The Capriole Fund has one goal: outperform Bitcoin.

We are open to professional investors, but the fund has limited spaces.

Share the Post:

2 Responses

  1. Great article, thanks!
    One comment on the spot trading volumes in BTC charts. While it’s true that the volume in BTC is low, isn’t so that the volume in $ is actually pretty robust (although not great)?
    Can another (complementary) interpretation be that Bitcoins are simply getting more scarce, so basically there is less Bitcoin available for sale?

    1. Yes this is true, it does look a bit better in USD terms. Though I like BTC terms for a ‘like for like’ comparable as the market grows. Nonetheless, even if you compare volumes today versus similar price points in 2021, volumes are lower. In conjunction with all the other metrics here, I think it paints the aggregate picture I suggest in “Implications” below. Especially when you look at Derivatives volumes and the decline of Perps against Options.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Disclaimer

The information contained here is provided to you solely for informational purposes only. Opinions and projections included are provided as of the date of publication, may prove to be inaccurate, and are subject to change without notice. This information does not constitute an offering. Prospective investors should not treat these materials as advice regarding legal, tax, or investment matters. No recommendations are made to invest in Capriole Investments Limited nor any other investment. An offering may be made only by delivery of a confidential offering memorandum to appropriate investors. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Investing in digital assets in general involves risk. Digital asset risks include, but are not limited to, exchange risk, legal risk, hacking risk, market risk, liquidity risk, trading risk and default risk. As with any investment, investing in digital assets could result in loss of investment. Additional digital asset risks are outlined at www.capriole.com/legal. Decisions or actions based on the information provided are at the reader’s own account and risk.

Related Posts

Update #56

With a president who has already launched multiple NFTs and cryptocurrencies in...

Charles Edwards

Update #55

Is retail dead? This issue we explore a conundrum that faces Bitcoin...

Charles Edwards

Update #54

Don't trust on-chain data. A lot of metrics have been manipulated in...

Charles Edwards

Update #53

Bitcoin is under pressure. But the most comparable asset to Bitcoin, at...

Charles Edwards

Update #52

Is the cycle top in? This issue, we will revisit the Bitcoin...

Charles Edwards

Update #51

Hash Ribbons is back. Perhaps the best long-term Bitcoin buy signal there...

Charles Edwards

Update #50

Is Bitcoin's longest winning streak finally coming to an end?...

Charles Edwards

Update #49

A dive on the forth Bitcoin Halving, Runes, Onchain valuations and macroeconomic...

Charles Edwards

Update #48

Welcome to Bitcoin price discovery, it's been a long time coming. With...

Charles Edwards

Update #47

The era of deep value is over. Bitcoin is fairly valued for...

Charles Edwards

Update #46

With the big Fidelity news, Bitcoin is finally being acknowledged in traditional...

Charles Edwards

Update #45

The brand names of these two behemoths in the traditional asset space...

Charles Edwards

Update #44

Today's Bitcoin ETF launch was the most successful launch in history and...

Charles Edwards

Update #43

ETF fever is coming to a head with approvals expected within the...

Charles Edwards

Update #42

Two major and positive events just unfolded in the Bitcoin space. According...

Charles Edwards

Update #41

Bitcoin is heating up, in both opportunity and across derivatives markets. And...

Charles Edwards

Issue #40

A new major trend has formed. We now have the biggest asset...

Charles Edwards

Issue #39

We have historically rare risk-asset signals appearing, amidst a period of Bitcoin's...

Charles Edwards

Issue #38

The last week has seen the biggest improvements across Bitcoin technicals and...

Charles Edwards

Issue #37

Bitcoin is pricing as a better-and-better inflation hedge. It is rapidly skewing...

Charles Edwards

Issue #36

The Fed is Building a War Chest. A macroeconomic deep dive to...

Charles Edwards

Issue #35

We are seeing some promising and rare structures form on Bitcoin which...

Charles Edwards

Issue #34

All else equal, Bitcoin is like a beach ball submerged underwater. Nonetheless,...

Charles Edwards

Issue #33

Last update technicals and fundamentals told us to be cautious with Bitcoin....

Charles Edwards

The Three Factor Model

90% of the S&P500 returns over the last half century can be...

Charles Edwards

Issue #32

Welcome to Capriole’s micro update #1. Where we consolidate the most important...

Charles Edwards

Issue #31

At $29K, Bitcoin’s on-chain fundamentals are not too hot and not too...

Charles Edwards

Issue #30

The failures of the Federal Reserve in managing the value of money...

Charles Edwards

Issue #29

This newsletter explores a taboo topic. The idea of the impossible, a...

Charles Edwards

Issue #28

Bitcoin’s deep value is slipping away and in its place a new...

Charles Edwards

Issue #27

We believe the 2020s will be the decade of hard money, much...

Charles Edwards

Why markets are not as overvalued as you might think.

Charles Edwards

Issue #26

The crypto world was shaken to the core in November as top...

Charles Edwards

Bitcoin Miner Sell Pressure

Charles Edwards

The Bitcoin Yardstick

Charles Edwards

Issue #25

We crack open the rarest of Bitcoin value metric readings you can...

Charles Edwards

Everything you need to know about yield curves

Charles Edwards

Issue #24

This month we deep dive into the macro and make the case...

Charles Edwards

SLRV Ribbons

Charles Edwards

Issue #23

Fear struck the market again with a blunt Fed speech. The broader...

Charles Edwards

Issue #22

This issue we deep dive into the many Bitcoin and macro metrics...

Charles Edwards

Issue #21

Today, we now find ourselves in a special juncture in the crypto...

Charles Edwards

The Digital Asset Thesis

Charles Edwards

The Capriole Macro Index

Charles Edwards

Issue #20

The S&P500 and Bitcoin showcased a strong recovery recently and today both...

Charles Edwards

Issue #19

Traditional markets have been taking a beating. Our February Newsletter and analysis...

Charles Edwards

Issue #18

The first quarter of 2022 is coming to a close. War in...

Ryan McCoy

Issue #17

For the past few months, Bitcoin has been driven by macro events...

Yassine Zrigui

Issue #16

Last month was mostly dominated by macro news much like December, namely...

Mick Herfkens

Capriole’s 2022 Market Outlook

A year ago, we published our “Christmas Special” newsletter. We wrote the...

Charles Edwards

Issue #15

If you have been around the cryptospace long enough, you have probably...

Ryan McCoy

Issue #14

Bitcoin started the month of November strong with a new all time...

Mick Herfkens

Issue #13

Bitcoin is up over 30% to date in October, reaching as high...

Charles Edwards

A Simple Metric to Identify Bitcoin Tops

Charles Edwards

Issue #12

Last issue, at $47K we noted some concerning metrics, but noted the...

Charles Edwards

Issue #11

Last issue we noted the improving fundamentals for Bitcoin...

Charles Edwards

Issue #10

Last issue we reviewed the China’s crypto exodus and argued why we...

Charles Edwards

Issue #9

These are unprecedented times. The Bitcoin network has just experienced the biggest...

Charles Edwards

Issue #8

Bitcoin is trading at more than 40% below the all-time high for...

Jan Uytenhout

Issue #7

Every month we write a short update on the market. We try...

Charles Edwards

Issue #6

Every month we write a short update on the market. Last issue,...

Jan Uytenhout

Issue #5

Every month we write a short update on the market. We try...

Charles Edwards

Issue #4

Every month we write a short update on the market. We try...

Jan Uytenhout

Issue #3

Every month we write a short update on the market. We try...

Charles Edwards

Issue #2

We try to release our newsletters when we see key opportunities. Today...

Jan Uytenhout

What is Money?

Charles Edwards

Issue #1

This newsletter provides our airplane view of the Bitcoin market. It summarises...

Charles Edwards

The Energy Standard

Charles Edwards

Bitcoin Energy-Value Equivalence

Charles Edwards

Bitcoin’s Production Cost

Charles Edwards

Hash Ribbons & Bitcoin Bottoms

Charles Edwards

Metcalfe’s Law Says Bitcoin is Overvalued

Charles Edwards

Bitcoin Valuation using Dynamic Range NVT Signal

Charles Edwards

The Next Resession

Charles Edwards

Bitcoin Bottom Fishing with Miner Capitulation

Charles Edwards